Pirates… low point!

Just saw PIRATES BAND OF MISFITS, which I loved. What fun!

One thing about animated films, they really remind me that they came from a script. Despite my years of experience of going to movies as well as writing them, live action films somehow seem real… like they just photographed real people in the middle of their day. No actors. No lighting. Just real life, with no script. I know, I know, it’s stupid. But that’s how deeply I get into a live action movie.

An animated film, though, is so 100% fake, that the writing shines through a little bit more clearly.

In PIRATES, one thing that came through is the main character’s low point. Wow, does he have one. And I noticed one thing about it, too. One interesting thing.

He loses everything.
All his friends.
All his money.
His ship.
Everything he holds dear.
He’s been deserted by his best friend.
And he’s at rock bottom. No way he could get any lower.

And…

There’s no way he can get out of his problem.

That’s the key to it all. There is no solution for the guy except to take up a life as a friendless loser who makes a living collecting change from phone booths. There is no way out of it. The deeper the hole that you, the writer, put your hero in, the better. The darker the hole, the better. Put him or her in a hole that you can’t figure out a way to escape from… then, keep thinking until you come up with a surprising, believable, and elegant solution. Then you are on the right track.

If you can’t figure out a solution to the hero’s deep-dark-hole problem over a period of two or three hours or days… the the movie going public won’t be able to figure it out in five minutes.

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Scenes, Screenwriting

2 responses to “Pirates… low point!

  1. Melody Lopez

    The ALL IS LOST moment in the Avengers movie… (to use Blake Snyder’s terms) was an interesting choice by the writers…but it wasn’t insanely great stuff because it wasn’t the same intense loss that you describe in this Pirate movie… in the AVENGERS (no spoiler alert cause I am high level about it)… what is lost was more of an ideal (or something that represented the ideal- which Blake Snyder would call -the death of an idea)…so this forced the Avenger’s team to dig down deep…and it was believable (considering everything else fantastic about the movie)…and then it got to the STORMING THE CASTLE PART of the movie and man…it was so well done…but just shy of being INSANELY GREAT… why? cause I didn’t cry- LOL regardless the movie was well done.

    My husband took the girls to see the Pirates movie (which I really wanted to see but had to work)… and he said he laughed out loud a couple times…but my girls are sophisticates now… they liked it…but they said it wasn’t INSANELY GREAT… but the lesson was definitely learned and understood…cause Melina told it to me… so that’s a big deal…

  2. So, once I have my hero in the deepest hole imaginable, HOW do I find the solution that’s both elegant AND believable? Anybody?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s